Village green beats development

Village green beats development

R (on the application of Lewis) v Redcar and Cleveland BC [2010] UKSC 11

Begonia Filgueira   |  14/03/2010

The Supreme Court has held that the local residents of Coatham have not lost their right to register land as a village green which has been used for local informal recreation (walking, picnics, etc) and as a private golf course for over 80 years.   The land in question forms an important part of the development site known as the Coatham Links coastal regeneration project - a 14 hectares mixed development site for residential and leisure.

Redcar and Cleveland BC had argued that use could not be 'as of right' for the purposes of section 15 of the Commons Act 2006 if local inhabitants were seen to have deferred to the primary use of the land for the purposes of golf.   Lord Walker, delivering the unanimous judgment, did not accept that walkers waiting until play had passed or until they were waived through by golfers was inconsistent with the phrase "as of right"; the right had not been lost:
'..simply because people normally showed civility - or in the inspector's words, deference - to members of the golf club......It is not as if the residents took to their heels and vacated the land whenever they saw a golfer…They simply acted with courtesy and common sense.'
Speaking about the case Kate Ashbrook General Secretary of the Open Spaces Society (which helps members register village greens):

 'This monumental decision clarifies the law on registering land as new greens.  The Supreme Court has said beyond all doubt that use of land as a green can coexist with the landowner's activities.     In the past, applications have been rejected merely because the local people were civil and deferred to the use by the landowner-whether he was making hay or playing golf.  We considered it unfair that people should be penalised for being polite, but it was proving a major problem for people wishing to record their recreational rights by registering land as a green.'


What's your opinion?  |   ADD COMMENT

Reply to a comment: Simply click reply underneath the comment. Once it has been approved your comment will appear below it.

You must be signed in to comment. To register click here.


The sleeping dragon awakes

I invite you to imagine a dragon who lives at the top of the world, sleeping. He has been there for as long as ...


Getting tough on wildlife crime

Over the past five years wildlife crime has doubled into a global trade worth $19 billion, making it the fourth...


Successful A1P1 claims

This is an important judgment


Sustainable Development + Rule of Law

The 26 March 2012 saw the launch of the World Congress on Justice, Governance and Law for Environmental Sustain...


The Government’s environmental policy

Stephen Sykes

Markets and businesses – environmental or otherwise - work best when the rules of trade are clear; when t...



Most popular stories

Environmental Liability Directive

Environmental Liability Directive

Slow transpositionFollowing the adoption of the environmental liability directive (ELD) in 2004, the story of its implementation by EU......

Books Find out more

Aluna - Film

Aluna - Film

Alan Ereira, Raindance Film Festival

This film documentary is about the Kogi...


Environmental Impact Assessment

Environmental Impact Assessment

Stephen Tromans QC, xxx

Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) has become central to...


Messages From the World

Messages From the World

United Nations Conference on Sustainable Development, Free

This is not a...